Morgul Marketing

    Where a Chicago brokerage's ad budget leaks, and what to bid on instead

    Paid search works for a brokerage, but not the way it works for a trade that books jobs by the week. Volume is thin, fees are large, and the broad phrase that looks cheap in the report is buying apartment hunters in Lakeview and vendors chasing snow removal contracts. An account here has to be built around three separate buyers: the occupier with a requirement, the owner deciding who lists the building, and the investor. Each needs its own budget, its own copy and its own landing page. Then the whole thing gets judged on booked tours and signed agreements, because cost per lead will flatter the campaign bringing you the wrong people. We would build it in that order, and we would not put a lead volume in writing before the first search terms report exists.

    Talk to us

    Snow removal contractors and Logan Square apartment hunters will spend your budget by Thursday

    Broad commercial phrases in this market pull renters, job seekers and vendors looking for work, so the exclusion list matters more than the bid.

    Commercial property Chicago and commercial building Chicago are not tenant phrases. They pull people hunting apartments in Logan Square and Lakeview, contractors looking for janitorial and plowing contracts, and students writing papers.

    Build the negative list before anything goes live: rent, apartment, studio, jobs, hiring, salary, cleaning, plowing, course, license, and the names of the portals your prospects are probably on.

    Read the search terms report weekly for the first month, then monthly. Fall adds its own contamination, because vendors and property managers start searching snow and ice contracts well before the first storm and every one of those queries looks commercial to a broad match.

    Exact and phrase match do most of the work in a market this thin. Broad match with an automated bid strategy and a short negative list is the fastest way to spend a quarter's budget on nothing.

    Will County distribution and a Ravenswood flex building are two different auctions

    Geography is not one dial in Chicagoland, and a single metro campaign will fund the cheapest clicks inside it.

    A distribution requirement out along the interstate corridors in Will County draws national competition, long lead times and expensive clicks. An infill flex building in Ravenswood with rear alley loading has a small, local, inexpensive audience.

    Separate them. Separate budgets, separate copy, separate landing pages. Left together, the system spends where clicks are cheap, which is rarely where the fee is.

    Target the market you serve rather than a radius around your office. Somebody sitting in the Loop can be shopping Naperville and somebody in Ohio can be shopping a Cicero box, so check the location setting carefully, because platform defaults change and the wrong one buys you sightseers.

    Name the county or the suburb in the ad copy. A headline that says Schaumburg stops the wrong click before it costs anything.

    Owner side searches are thin, expensive, and the only ones that hand you inventory

    Tenant demand pays this month; owner demand is what fills next year, and it needs its own budget and its own patience.

    Phrases about selling a building, appointing a listing agent or requesting a management proposal have low volume and high value. They will never look impressive in a report. They fill a calendar.

    Ring fence that budget so the tenant campaigns cannot starve it. Occupier keywords will always win on cost per lead and will never bring you an exclusive.

    The landing page is different too. An owner is not browsing your availability. They want to know what you would do with their building, who would work it, and what you have leased or sold nearby.

    Small multifamily deserves separate treatment. An owner of two-flats and three-flats on the North Side is not shopping the same firm as an institutional seller, and one generic sellers page speaks to neither of them.

    Shift the mix in January, when tenants stall and owners plan

    Demand here has a seasonal shape, and a budget spread evenly across twelve months is out of step with it in both directions.

    Tours generally slow through the hard weeks of winter. Occupier searches do not disappear, but decisions stretch, and a tenant campaign running at full spend during a bad stretch is buying attention that will not convert this month.

    The same weeks put owners in front of their buildings. A capital bid, a heating bill, a frozen line in a vacant suite, all of it moves the disposition question up the list.

    Move money accordingly. More toward the owner side and investment sales in the cold months, more toward occupier campaigns in spring and early fall.

    Do not read one storm week as a trend. Check your own two previous winters in the CRM before you move budget on the season, because the shape is familiar in Chicago brokerages but the size of it is yours. Pace against that, and keep the account stable enough that you can compare one winter honestly with the next.

    A dead Skokie listing behind a live ad costs you the click and the callback

    Paid traffic punishes stale availability harder than anything else on your site, because you paid for the disappointment.

    Every campaign should land on a page whose inventory matches the promise in the ad. If the ad says Skokie industrial, the page shows Skokie industrial, today.

    When a building leases, somebody has to touch the campaign that same week. Put it in the process, not in somebody's memory.

    Keep leased buildings online with the status shown and a route to something comparable. Deleting the page throws away the link and whatever search history came with it.

    The fix we would reach for before any bid change is one person owning the connection between the availability list and the live ads, named in the process and expected to touch it weekly.

    Smart bidding starves on brokerage volume, so give it a signal earlier than the lease

    One metro and a handful of monthly inquiries will not feed an automated strategy, so the account needs a conversion it can actually count.

    Leases are rare and slow. An algorithm optimizing toward them is optimizing toward noise. Pick a signal further up the funnel: a qualified inquiry, a document request, a phone call that lasted long enough to be real.

    Instrument the phone. Commercial inquiry often arrives as a call rather than a form, and an account that cannot see calls is bidding on an incomplete picture. Find out what your own split is before you decide how much that matters.

    Judge the account on the number that matters to the firm. Cost per booked tour first, cost per signed agreement once you have enough of them to say anything. Cost per lead is the metric that hides the problem.

    Push the CRM stage back into the platform where the integration allows it. Even a rough offline import teaches the system which clicks turned into work.

    Questions we get

    What should we budget monthly?
    There is no honest figure without looking at your submarkets and asset classes, because click costs vary enormously between an infill retail search and a national distribution phrase. The structural answer is better: fund one or two campaigns at a level where they get meaningful volume rather than spreading a small budget across eight. A starved campaign teaches you nothing.
    Should we run LinkedIn alongside search?
    For owner and investor audiences it is often worth testing, because you can reach the person who signs rather than waiting for them to search. Treat it as a different job with different creative and a longer horizon. Search captures a requirement that already exists; the professional networks introduce you before one does.
    Do we bid on competitors' brand names?
    Sometimes it is worth it and it is rarely cheap. In a market with this many established firms, a competitor click can be a real requirement that has not settled on anyone. Keep the copy factual and about your own coverage, watch the conversion rate closely, and stop if the clicks are just people looking for that firm's front desk.
    Should we pause the account in winter?
    Pausing loses the account's learning and the pipeline that follows the cold months. Shifting is better. Reduce occupier spend when tours are slipping, increase owner side and investment sales, and keep enough tenant coverage running that you are still present when the thaw comes.
    Our brokers get calls on their cell phones. How do we know what ads produced?
    Use tracked numbers on the landing pages so the source is captured at the moment of the call, and agree one habit with the brokers: log where the inquiry came from before the call ends. Neither is complicated, and without them the account is being judged on form fills, which is where most brokerage advertising goes wrong.

    Rules that affect your marketing

    Brokerage is licensed and advertising generally has to identify the brokerage rather than only the individual. The more practical constraint is that this industry is bought at submarket grain: a downtown tower and a suburban flex park are different products with different tenants, and content pitched at a whole metro tends to speak to neither.

    Written by KC Thompson, Morgul Marketing. Updated .

    Talk to us about paid ads for commercial real estate firms in Chicago

    Tell us about your business and where your marketing stands. We'll tell you what we'd do first, and what we'd leave alone.

    We won't add you to a mailing list. A person will reply.