Industries

    Websites for insurance agencies, built for clients as well as prospects

    Insurance agency websites tend to be built entirely for prospects, which is odd given that the people who use them most are already clients. Somebody needs a certificate, wants to know what their deductible is, has had an accident and cannot remember what to do, or needs to add a vehicle. They arrive at a site designed to sell them a policy they already have. Fixing that is straightforward, and it improves retention, which in a renewing business is worth more than the acquisition the site was built for. Licensing and advertising rules are state by state and belong with your compliance contact.

    Say which carriers you represent

    It is the clearest thing an independent agency can publish and most of them do not.

    The independent agency argument is access to multiple markets. That claim is abstract until the carriers are named, at which point a visitor can evaluate it.

    It also does practical work. Somebody with a preference, or somebody who has been declined by a particular carrier, is looking for exactly this information.

    Carriers usually have requirements about how their names and logos may be used in agency advertising, so this is worth checking against your agreements rather than assuming.

    Keep it accurate, since appointments change. A carrier listed that you can no longer place with produces an inquiry you have to decline.

    For specialty markets in particular, naming access is a genuine differentiator, because a prospect who has been turned down elsewhere is searching specifically for somebody who has it.

    Be honest about what the quote path can deliver

    A form implying an instant number, followed by a call three days later, loses the prospect and the goodwill.

    Some coverage can be quoted quickly and much of it cannot, and the website should be clear about which is which rather than implying one experience for everything.

    Long forms are the recurring failure. Asking for details a producer could gather in conversation, before anybody has spoken, produces abandonment nobody measures.

    The useful version asks the minimum to make contact and states what happens next: who will call, how quickly, and whether a number will be provided on that call.

    For commercial and specialty coverage, presenting it as a conversation rather than a quote form sets the right expectation and attracts a better prospect.

    Where a form is embedded from a carrier or a rater, test it on a phone. These are frequently the slowest and least usable components on an agency website.

    Let existing clients serve themselves

    Most of the traffic on an agency site is people who already pay you, and the site is usually built as though they do not exist.

    Clients arrive wanting a certificate, an ID card, a policy document, a payment, or an answer about what to do after an accident.

    Every one of those handled by the site is a call the office does not take, and a client who feels served rather than obstructed.

    The claims page is the most important of these and the most often missing. What to do immediately, who to call, what to document, and what the agency will do.

    Payments and document access usually run through carrier portals, which means the agency site's job is to make getting to the right one obvious rather than to rebuild it.

    Label things the way clients say them rather than the way the industry does. Somebody wants proof of insurance, not a declarations page, and the navigation should meet them there.

    Commercial clients need certificates, and they need them today

    Certificate requests are the most common commercial service demand and they are almost always urgent.

    A contractor cannot start work, a tenant cannot sign a lease, a vendor cannot be onboarded until a certificate arrives. The request is routine and the timing rarely is.

    An agency that makes this easy is solving the problem its commercial clients experience most often, and it is the thing they will describe when somebody asks about you.

    The site's job is a clear path: how to request one, what information is needed, how quickly it will arrive, and who to contact if it is urgent.

    Setting expectations on turnaround matters more than speed alone. A client who knows it takes a few hours plans around it; one who does not know calls three times.

    The same applies to other recurring commercial requests, such as adding an insured or updating a schedule. Those are the interactions that define whether the relationship feels well run.

    License and disclosure display is not decoration

    Producer licensing and advertising requirements reach the website, and the rules differ by state.

    State insurance departments regulate advertising, and requirements can include how an agency identifies itself, what license information appears and what disclosure accompanies a quote or an offer.

    An agency licensed in several states may be under several sets of requirements at once, and language acceptable in one may not be in another.

    Comparative and savings language is the recurring hazard, and it is exactly what performance-oriented copywriting produces.

    Describing coverage on the site raises its own questions, since a plain-language summary of a policy is still a representation about what it does.

    Have the site's product and offer language reviewed by your compliance contact rather than composed for persuasiveness alone. The exposure attaches to the licensed agency.

    Your footprint depends on licensing and appointments

    The structure above suits any agency. What the site can offer does not.

    Where you are licensed and which carriers you can place with in each state bounds what the site can honestly say it does and for whom.

    Which industries concentrate locally shapes which commercial content is worth building and which certificates you will be asked for most.

    We work through market specifics one at a time, and we are glad to look at your site with you.

    Questions we actually get

    Should we list the carriers we represent?
    It is the clearest way to make the independent agency argument concrete, and it helps somebody who has a preference or has been declined elsewhere. Check your carrier agreements first, since most have requirements about how their names and logos may be used, and keep the list accurate as appointments change.
    Our quote form gets abandoned. What is wrong with it?
    Usually length and expectation. It asks for details a producer could gather in conversation before anybody has spoken, and it implies an instant number for coverage that cannot be quoted quickly. Ask the minimum to make contact, and say who will call and how fast.
    What should we add for existing clients?
    A claims page saying what to do immediately and who to call, a clear path to certificates, and obvious links to carrier portals for payments and documents. Most of your site traffic is people who already pay you, and every request the site handles is a call the office does not take.
    How important are certificates?
    For commercial clients they are the most frequent and most urgent thing they need from you, since work cannot start and leases cannot be signed without one. Publish how to request one, what is needed and what the turnaround is. Expectations matter as much as speed.
    Are there rules about what our website can say?
    Yes, and they vary by state. Departments regulate advertising, including how an agency identifies itself, what license information appears and what disclosure accompanies a quote. Savings and comparison language is the usual hazard. Have product and offer copy reviewed by your compliance contact.

    What is different here

    Producer licensing is state by state, and so is most of what an agency may say. Advertising rules from a state insurance department can govern how a policy is described, which comparisons are allowed, and what disclosure a quote has to carry, so an agency appointed in several states may be working under several sets of rules at once. Worth clearing product-specific copy with a compliance contact before it runs.

    Written by KC Thompson, Morgul Marketing. Updated .

    Talk to us about web design for insurance agencies

    Tell us the market you work in and what the account looks like now. We will say where we would start, and what we would not touch yet.

    No newsletter, no drip sequence. One reply from a person.