Nobody in the five boroughs wins the category term outright
The two-word head term is already bought and paid for, so the plan starts by giving it up in writing.
Search the plain category phrase on a phone in Manhattan and look at what comes back. Directories, lead marketplaces, national remodeling brands and a design platform or two. Those positions rest on link profiles and content budgets built over years. A ten-person shop does not displace them, and a year spent trying is a year with nothing to show.
The queries underneath are worth more per visitor. Someone typing about combining two small bathrooms in a prewar apartment is far closer to hiring than someone typing two generic words. Fewer searchers, better ones, and almost nobody writing for them properly.
Build the target list from three ingredients. Place, meaning Park Slope, Astoria, Riverdale, Bay Ridge, the Upper West Side. Building, meaning brownstone, prewar walk-up, postwar elevator co-op, new condo. Problem, meaning a wet wall that cannot move, a steam riser in the corner, a galley with nowhere to put a dishwasher.
Write the surrender down in the plan. If the head term stays on the reporting sheet, somebody will judge nine months of good work against a ranking that was never available.