Your first screen has one job: settle the river question
Before a photo, a badge or a founding year, the visitor needs to know whether their address is one you serve.
Put the service area at the top in words, not in a map graphic that loads slowly and reads badly on a phone. Name Jefferson County and Louisville Metro, name the outlying counties you take, and say plainly whether you cross into Clark or Floyd County.
Real place names do the work. St. Matthews, Jeffersontown, Middletown, Prospect, Crescent Hill on the Kentucky side. Jeffersonville, New Albany, Clarksville if you go.
Then one phone number and one action. A slideshow of roofs is not an action.
If you do not serve Indiana, say so. A visitor who leaves in four seconds because you were honest costs you nothing. A canceled appointment costs a half day.